Family office investments that increase property portfolio returns by 50%
The below is not personal finanical advice.
Family office investments
We share the family office investment strategies that we’ve architected with our clients to generate them alpha returns for their individual investments and portfolios.
These strategies have helped family offices to increase property returns by up to 50%, increase private credit returns by up to 40% and have allowed them to diversify into venture capital investments, without exposing their core principal.
These strategies take advantage of how the Australian financial system works, using a combination of financial lending pricing arbitrage, property, underwriting and private credit (also known as private lending to borrowers).
Below we breakdown each of the components of the strategy, before presenting you with three core investments strategies.
How the financial system works?
The financial trinity
In Australia, there is a trinity that exists that most investors aren’t aware of between property, bank capital and private credit. In the background to this trinity is the tax system, which indirectly influences the decisions investors make. The principals of the trinity are as such.
- Banks lend cheap capital to good credit score borrowers with property as security.
- Property is a mechanism to counter the effects of inflation to obtain cheap capital from a bank, that can be reinvested for higher returns.
- Private credit takes the same pysical security as banks, but charges more for it in most instances.
- The tax system penalises those that crystalise assets.
- Equity within property grows over time and allows you to borrow more against it with time.
It is important you are aware of the above for you to conceptually understand the strategies that we present below.
The problem most property investors have with private credit
The problem most property investors have with private credit, is that they don’t fully understand it. A better way to look at it, is in the following way. If you’re willing to buy a property for $1M, with a 3% rental yield, why wouldn’t you lend against that very same property at 70% of its value, for a 10% p.a. return, and a first mortgage as security?
Why private credit is so important the investment strategy?
Private credit that is first mortgage backed against property on an as is basis, is a capital stable investment and one of the safest private investments on the market.
Our strategy is reliant on using cheap bank capital to invest in other investments, which offer higher returns that offer certainty, one of which is private credit.
First mortgage private credit provides certainty
- Certainty of legally obligated income to be paid.
- Certainty of instrument maturity date.
- Certainty of security for the funds provided.
- Certainty of the capital maintaining its value, without variance in value.
- Certainty of legal recourse.
Most of our clients invest in private credit funds, as well as doing direct lending themselves using us as originators. Direct lending investments provide up to 40% higher net returns that comparable funds against similar assets, and provide full deal control to the investor.
What is an alpha return?
We have purposely used the term “alpha return” in this article, and alpha return is defined as.
- When one investment can provide a higher return to a comparable investment that has a similar level of risk. In other words, a higher return could be achieved without taking on additional risk.
- When one investment can achieve the same level of return as another investment, but with less risk.
The way we achieve alpha returns at Royce Stone Capital, is through unique product architecture, deal structuring and underwriting. Below we reveal some of the strategies we use with family offices to generate alpha.
Family office investment strategies to generate alpha
Below we list the strategies that you can replicate on a smaller scale, to generate the same alpha returns that we help our clients achieve.
How to increase property investment returns by up to 50% or more
Our family office clients increase their property portfolio returns, by providing their property as security to source cheap bank capital. They then invest this money, in direct lending private credit investments. The beautify of this strategy, is that the whole investment strategy is 100% property backed in all directions. This combination of property, private credit and bank capital increases property portfolio returns by up to 50% or more.
The Financial arbitrage
The family office uses its own credit profile and property portfolio to source cheap bank capital. It then takes that capital and sells that very same money on private credit markets that are first mortgage backed.
Essentially, they are taking the same property security that a bank would take, but are making a profit on the arbitrage between their credit profile, and that of the borrower taking the private credit loan.
The mechanics
- Family office has a commercial property portfolio worth $50M, that generates them a 6% yield or $3M.
- They borrow from the bank $30M at 60% LVR at 7% p.a. which is $2.1M in interest cost.
- They deploy that $30M in private credit direct lending at 12% net returns ($3.6M).
- They profit 5% in the pricing difference, which is $1.5M.
- Now their total property portfolio, produces a return of $4.5M ($3M rental income, and $1.5M profit in the pricing arbitrage), which is 50% higher, than just having rental income.
The benefits
- The family office will be able to borrow more, as their property value increases. Which further increases the portfolio economics of using this strategy.
- This model is based on high commercial property income, if the property base was residential at 3% yield, you’d be seeing much higher returns.
- They have invested in private credit without crystalising assets and having to pay CGT.
- The cost of capital from the bank, is a tax deduction.
- Smaller investors can do the same thing, for example, if they have a $2M of unencumbered property and the ability to borrow money from the bank. This allows them to borrow $1.2M to invest in first mortgage private credit.
Generating alpha returns by underwriting risk
Higher returns, don’t have to come from taking on higher risk. What is risky for one investor, may not be for another, that can mitigate for that risk.
The underwriting
Our family office clients generate second mortgage private credit returns of 20% to 28% p.a. , and to do so with high first mortgage deal risk instead of second mortgage deal risk. They can do this, because they have the ability to underwrite / payout the first mortgage lender, in an event of default by the second mortgage borrower.
The mechanics
- A borrower has a $10M property, with a $5M first mortgage bank loan.
- The borrower requires a second mortgage loan of $2.5M (gross).
- Total combined loan LVR of first and second is 75%.
- The family office provide the $2.5M through our direct lending’s investments, for a 26% net yield.
- The family office has the financial capacity, that if the borrower defaults, to payout the $5M bank loan and take total control of the asset. In that instance, they would have a high first mortgage loan, as opposed to a second mortgage position that is at the mercy of the bank.
The benefits
- The ability to exercise full control of the asset.
- Our investors aren’t at the mercy of a first mortgage lender.
- Second mortgage returns, for high first mortgage risk.
- Smaller investors can do the same thing if they have the ability to write a $200k second mortgage cheque and the ability to underwrite a $500k to $1.5M of first mortgage debt. As is the case with most of our private credit transactions.
The risk-free carry trade
This strategy works to use the investment returns of capital stable investments, to invest in higher risk investments, without putting at risk the principal capital. It also allows family office to take on riskier investments, generate higher returns, and claim tax deductions.
The carry
Family offices have two choices, when investment returns come in. They can park that money, and let inflation eat it away, or they can actively invest the funds.
The returns from capital stable investments such as first mortgage-backed private credit, allow portfolios to take on riskier investments that provide higher returns, such as venture capital investments, private equity or second mortgages.
In total the portfolio benefits from diversification, and if the higher risk investments fail, the investor can claim a capital loss.
The mechanics
- A family office has private credit first mortgage direct lending investments of $50M with a 10% return.
- Net returns are $5M.
- If the tax rate is 25%, this means $1.25M of tax is applied.
- If the inflation rate is 3%, this means $1.5M is needed to cover the effects of inflation.
- This means, total real returns post tax of $2.25M.
- That $2.25M is taken and then invested in private equity at 20% return p.a. or second mortgage loans. This now delivers a gross return of $450k without any additional risk to the principal funds of $50M.
- Or the $2.25M can be put into various venture capital investments.
Key benefits
- This means total portfolio gross returns in the following year will be $5.45M vs $5M, so the portfolio is 9% better off in real terms, with no additional risk to the original $50M.
- The effects are compounding if the funds are reinvested every year.
- If the funders are invested in second mortgage loans, and underwritten using our previous strategy, the portfolio is further derisked.
- Smaller investors can do the same thing, on a smaller scale.
To lean more about private credit click here.
To learn more about direct lending investments click here.
To learn more about venture capital investments click here.
