The below is not personal financial advice
Borrowers, especially business borrowers are facing a reckoning as their loans mature during a falling property market, and loan LVRs jump out of control. This not only effects borrowers, but also those providing credit to them, banks, second tier lenders and private lenders. In this article we discuss the causes, and what both sides of the fence need to do.
The political parties whether it be Labor, the Liberals or One Nation have all stated they wanted to reduce property prices. This is great in theory, but in practice is far from practical for the Australian economy.
As a nation, you can’t have the fourth highest household debt in the world and then aim to reduce the value of the very asset that secures most of that debt, without someone paying the delta.
The catch 22 for the politicians
There are several mechanisms by which to reduce property prices, some are better than others. The current Labor government opted for CGT changes, a ban on SMSF residential lending and negative gearing changes to name a few.
Regardless of which mechanisms were going to be used, the catch 22 for any government tackling the issue was that whilst they may want property prices to drop, if prices fell too quickly, they risked major pain being caused to the economy. Which is where we are now.
Hard landing versus soft landing of property prices
In our opinion, what Australia needed was a soft landing approach over years or a decade, not a year as we are currently experiencing. Right now, we have a range of issues, that clearly demonstrates why we can’t afford lower property prices, and everyone is paying a price.
- Existing borrowers, that have high LVR loans, will struggle to refinance in the current environment. If they borrowed at 80% LVR a year or two ago, and need to refinance today. As their current LVRs are probably sitting at 85% LVR to 90% LVR at present. Without providing extra equity or cash, they are forced to sell.
- Construction loans are based on lending against the end value of a project GRV / NRV at the time of a loan. If a project has commenced, and the end value drops during the process of construction, this leaves the developer with less profit if any, and puts the lender at risk of not getting the funds they are owed. It also puts second mortgage lenders and mezzanine lenders at greater risk.
- Investors that invested in property development funds / projects, are getting burnt from both ends. Falling property prices, and rising construction costs, as well as higher borrowing costs.
- If property prices fall, people intrinsically feel poorer, and are less likely to spend. Already a number of our business clients are complaining that spending is down.
The numbers don’t lie either, Insolvency’s are 75% higher than pre 2021 levels, and unemployment recently came in at 4.9%. Which will further climb as the recent rate rises take full effect. But the real canary in the coal mine has been the fact that real wages have been going backwards for some time now. Builder insolvencies, have risen 180% since 2021, and construction is the leading industry for all insolvencies.
The deals aren’t stacking up even for private credit
Normally when the banking system has a problem, the private credit market / shadow banking system is there to save the day, as private credit accepts higher levels of risk than banks. However, in the current market a lot of borrower situations aren’t even adding up for private credit funds.
To make matters worse, some private credit construction funds have been caught up in the above mess, with several private credit funds putting a freeze on redemptions.
Other private credit provides are still highly profitable and are absorbing the deals that others don’t have capacity to write.
At Royce Stone Capital because of our direct lending investments, we haven’t had the above issues that other private credit funds have had. As we are primarily focused on lending to business owners, that need capital for a business venture, taking property, heritage plates and alternative assets as security. Our primary exit is a business venture occurring, not an underlying property transaction (as is the case with construction loans).
LVR maintenance clauses
Most loan documents, especially for private credit providers, have within them LVR maintenance clauses. This legal clause that states the borrowers must maintain the LVR of the loan, if there is a fall in the underlying asset value, by providing additional funds / equity.
However realistically, in the current environment, most borrowers, don’t have additional equity or cash to contribute.
This leaves the lenders, banks, second tier lends and private lenders, with one of two options. Work with the borrower or enforce and sell the asset. Whilst selling an asset might seems like a solution, in a dry property environment, selling the asset may not always be the best thing.
This also means that wholesale investors, investing in private investments like private credit, must be patient for their capital, which most are within reason.
What borrows and lenders both need to do
The economic enviorment
Firstly, all parties need to realise that the current environment isn’t any one person’s fault, a range of issues have hit at the same time (inflation, geopolitical conflicts, government policy, RBA policies etc). We don’t dismiss though, there have been greedy and incompetent players from all sides of the fence, who are now getting exposed.
Looking at historical prices in real terms of property a few things that become clear. Property prices in the last two decades have been recovering a lot quicker, that decades preceding them. This is in part, due to the fiat currency system we have, that keeps pushing up asset values. Secondly, if unemployment continues to rise, governments and the RBA will need to take some sort of competent action (we hope its competent).
The underlying risk, however, to this whole situation is that we could enter a period of stagflation. Which is high inflation, with high unemployment. In which case, the only real place to park capital would be in real assets, businesses that are essential or instruments secured by real assets.
Practical steps for borrowers and lenders
If borrowers and lenders can both see a way out, in a year or two. Then lenders need to work with borrowers, to maintain the status quo, if selling the underlying assets in the short term isn’t in everyone’s best interests.
This will require give and tack on both sides.
This might look like the following.
- Borrowers paying interest every month, instead of them paying P&I or capitalising interest.
- Borrowers paying interest and a small portion of principal, if they had interest only loans to reduce high LVRs.
- Lenders charging the base rate of interest instead of the penalty rate of interest.
- Lenders extending loan maturity.
- Lenders looking at converting part of their debt into equity.
To read more about private credit click here.
To read more about direct lending investments click here.
To read more about private lending click here.
To have a confidential discussions click here.
